Home  / UK / Government Register for Membership

HM Treasury Analyse Scottish Government's Defecit Forecast

Published on 11 March 2014

Discover the World Of Judaica

by The Rt Hon Alistair Carmichael MP


London, England

New analysis produced by the Treasury today shows the Scottish Government’s deficit forecast for the first year of independence is billions of pounds out of step with all other recent forecasts.

Scottish Secretary Alistair Carmichael said this was further evidence that Scottish Government Ministers will say anything to try and win the independence referendum.

The Treasury paper published today shows that the most recent forecasts from the Centre for Public Policy and the Regions (CPPR), the Institute of Fiscal Studies (IFS), Citi Group and HM Treasury all estimate Scotland’s deficit in 2016-17 at between 5.1 and 5.4% of GDP. The Scottish Government’s most cautious forecast is 3.2 per cent which is more than £3bn more optimistic than all the others.

Mr Carmichael said that Alex Salmond’s faith in higher oil revenues in the future was undermined by the fact that the Scottish Government’s independence white paper relied on a ‘forecast’ that predicted revenues of almost £7bn for 2012-13 when the actual figures had already been published by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) and the Scottish Government’s geographic share would be almost £1bn lower.

Alistair Carmichael said:

"It is no surprise that Alex Salmond is the odd man out when it comes to predicting the deficit that would confront an independent Scotland. He will say anything to try and disguise the problems of independence. He will say anything to try and win this referendum.

"I totally accept that people are suspicious when politicians start throwing figures around. All I am asking is that people in Scotland listen to what outside experts are saying. The Treasury forecasts are very much in line with three of the most recent studies from respected economic analysts. These analysts have no axe to grind and are simply offering their expert view.

"Trust and credibility are vitally important in this debate. The Scottish Government don’t help their case when their white paper relies on an oil revenue forecast that has already proved to be over-optimistic in 2012-13 by almost £1 billion. That is not optimism. That is saying anything to try and win a referendum."

For more information about this press release visit https://www.gov.uk/government/news/hm-treasury-analyse-scottish-governments-defecit-forecast



Enter your email:
Enter Subject:
Enter your message:
Please enter this numbers in the fields:
  Click image to get a new code.
Enter code:

Posted 2014-03-11 18:48:00